Music Therapy in the public school system
Parents, Therapists and Teachers:
Please read ALL of the information provided on these pages carefully, particularly noting the difference between the two ways in which music therapy can be provided in the public schools. Always work towards cooperation NOT confrontation when requesting a music therapy assessment and/or services.
In this section of the website, we cover:
- Music Therapy as a Related Service (assessment required)
- Why some school districts choose to voluntarily provide music therapy as an educational enrichment service (no assessment required)
- Things to think about BEFORE you request a music therapy assessment
Five things to remember about music therapy in the public schools
MUSIC THERAPY IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS may be provided in one of two ways
--By Decision of the IEP Committee (Assessment Based)
--By decision of the school district
The IEP committee, at the request of a parent or a school district representative, may request a music therapy assessment for a particular student. The assessment must be administered by a board-certified music therapist (MT-BC) and the process (records review, interviews, observation, MT assessment, report preparation) usually takes 4-6 hours. The purpose of the music therapy assessment is to determine whether music therapy is necessary for the student to benefit from his/her education. This is decided by looking at whether or not music provides the student with a significant motivation and/or a significant assist in participating in his or her educational program. A comprehensive music therapy assessment will include a music therapy evaluation that has been designed to address the specific goals and objectives of the student in question, and an observation in the classroom so that a comparison can be made. A student may "enjoy" music, but perform no better in a music therapy structure than he or she does in a regular classroom. A student may readily participate and successfully complete functional tasks in music therapy, but the goals achieved must be listed in the IEP. Again, a related service like music therapy is provided ONLY when it has been shown to be necessary for the student to benefit from his or her educational program.
Once the music therapy assessment has been completed, the IEP committee meets to review the report and recommendations. If the IEP committee, including the parent or guardian, agrees with the findings of the music therapy report (recommendation or denial), that decision is legally binding. If the service is recommended, it must be provided. Decision about the need for a particular related service is reviewed annually. A student may continue to receive the service if educational need is again established; service provision may be changed if the student's performance changes; or servce may be discontinued if it is no longer necessary.
MUSIC THERAPY ASSESSMENT CRITERIA
These questions may help members of a student's IEP committee determine the appropriateness of a music therapy assessment. Before contacting a music therapist to perform an assessment, the following questions should be discussed and answered by the parent(s)/guardian(s) of the student, the teacher of the student and at least one other district representative. A "no" response to one or more questions does not necessarily mean that a student is inappropriate for a music therapy assessment. If disagreements or questions arise, a music therapist should be contacted.
--Can the student be motivated to attempt tasks through the use of music?
--Can the student be motivated to complete tasks through the use of music?
--Could the student benefit from the use of additional communication modalities?
--Does the student initiate interaction with music or musical instruments in the classroom or in the home?
--Does the student retain information conveyed in songs more easily than information conveyed in spoken interchanges?
***By decision of the School District (Educational Consult)
Who decides? With this approach, the school district (not the IEP committee) makes the decision to identify and prioritize groups of students who could benefit specifically from music therapy intervention. Groups of students that are prioritized often include those who, due to disability and/or age, have difficulty benefiting from traditional types of school instruction. These groups might include: students in early childhood programs, students with autism, students with severe/profound disabilities and students with multiple disabilities.
The IEP: Service provided in this manner is described as "consult to teacher and/or program". Assessments are NOT conducted for each individual student, and specific music therapy goals and objectives do NOT appear on the students' IEP's. Most importantly, music therapy is NOT listed as a related service for the students who are receiving the consult service. However, a description of the student's class/program may include a statement like, "a music therapist serves as an educational consultant to the ________ class."
Service Delivery: As an educational consultant, the music therapist makes regular visits to each designated classroom, conducting sessions which serve as models for the teachers and aides. Those staff then carry out the music therapy program during the time period between visits. The music therapist might come weekly to the classroom or every other week: the frequency of the consult visits is determined by the school district. There is a strong focus in this model on assisting the teacher to use music throughout each day as an effective educational tool. Visual aid patterns, tapes and other materials are provided to the teacher on a regular basis by the music therapy consultant.
Service Review: When music therapy service is provided in this manner, it is the district's decision as to whether or not service is continued or discontinued. Provision of service in this manner cannot be legally mandated by the IEP committee.
Benefits of the Educational Enrichment Model of Music Therapy
(provided by "decision of the school district")
**The amount of time and resources used to assess and serve one or two students could just as effectively be used to serve the whole classroom. The cost is then spread across a larger number of students. Music therapy is a wonderful way to encourage development and learning in infants and toddlers. Music stimulates all of the senses and involves the child at many levels. Quality learning and participation occur because music is highly motivating.
**Teachers gain skills that they can use on a regular basis to effectively and consistently intervene with students. The abilities of the teachers and other staff personnel are strengthened and enhanced.
**When only one or two students have music therapy in their IEP's, few teachers have contact with the music therapist because he or she comes to only a few classrooms, and pulls students out into a separate room for the sessions. Teachers lose the opportunity to learn effective intervention techniques that could lessen their frustration in working with their most challenging students. Providing teachers with innovative ideas and stimulating their own creativity can be a way to motivate them and reduce turnover.
**When music therapy is provided to just a few, designated students, the district misses an opportunity for positive public relations. A school district can benefit from the public's knowledge that it utilizes a cost effective, innovative strategy in meeting the needs of its students.
**While parents still have the right to request that the IEP committee evaluate music therapy's role in their child's IEP, music therapy's involvement in a greater number of classrooms usually means that the frequency of high cost evaluations and direct service will decrease significantly.
**Most students with disabilities have social and language deficits that are best addressed within a group setting. "Pull-out" therapy does not give the student the advantage of learning and working within a peer group- and the teacher does not benefit from observing if the student is pulled out of the classroom for therapy.
**Music therapy is particularly effective in addressing several different levels of skill in a single group. Teachers who have learned through the consult program model may find that music therapy gives them an opportunity to work with their entire class while at the same time giving particular students chances to work on specific goals.
5 Things to Remember
1. Music therapy *is* a related service: this was originally stated in the congressional report on IDEA and it recently has been affirmed by the federal Office of Special Education.
2. The only way for music therapy to be placed on an IEP as a related service is through an assessment conducted by a qualified music therapist.
3. Music therapy may be provided as an educational consult service to a group of students (early childhood or autism programs, for example) - and this may provide more children with service and teachers with materials they can use on a daily basis - but it should *not* be listed as a related service on any student's IEP if that student has not received an individual assessment.
4. An assessment for music therapy as a related service should, at minimum, include a review of the student's current IEP, interviews with key IEP team members, and an assessment process/instrument that provides specific data as to whether or not music therapy makes a significant difference in a student's ability to benefit from his or her IEP.
5. The standard for recommending music therapy in the public schools (according to the federal law) is usually more stringent than that for therapy in other settings. While a child may enjoy music and even "benefit" from the inclusion of music in the education and therapy, in order for music therapy to be recommended as a related service, it must be "required" for a child to benefit from his or her special education program.
6 Tips for Using Music in Therapy & Education
1. Use silence. Once we know a piece of music, we notice when it is interrupted. You can use unexpected pauses in music to get the attention of students whose attention has wandered. Once you have their attention back, you can resume exactly where you left off - like the pause button on a tape player. No verbal cues necessary¤..just silence!
2. Make sure the lyrics fit the music. When you are using songs to teach academic concepts - especially to students with language delays - be sure that the words and phrases in the song are pronounced as they would be in speech. Often, when songs are "piggybacked" (new words with familiar melody) the words get distorted. Many children with special needs learn speech through singing; if they learn to pronounce words incorrectly, it may take a long tie to unlearn.
3. Use Quality Instruments. Rather than buying a "bargain box" filled with instruments that have a bad sound quality as well as being breakable (or even dangerous), choose a few high quality instruments that your students can share. We recommend a paddle drum, a wooden clatterpillar, a small cabasa and a transparent rainstick as a start. All are visually interesting, appropriate for older as well as younger students, and have unique intriguing sounds. Go to West Music and request a catalog - they have all of these instruments and a music therapist on staff with whom you can consult about other ideas.
4. Use Music with discretion. Do you hear your refrigerator buzzing? Most of us don't - because we've gotten so used to it, we block it out. If music is an effective tool, use it when you need it most. Playing music all day won't make children smarter; it will just teach them to tune it out.
5. Include by adapting. A few simple adaptations will help in including children with special needs in a regular education music setting. If the class is learning to play the recorder, for example, the music teacher can identify one or two "pedal" tones for each piece; the child with special needs can play just those two notes on a recorder, or on a resonator bell, for example. Children who cannot participate in singing can play rhythm instruments to accompany their peers.
6. Use Live Music & You *CAN* Sing!! Live music is, in most cases, much more effective than recorded music. If you sing the songs, you can change the tempo and volume according to the mood and behavior of the class, you can pause to allow time for responses or to cue attention (see above), and you can change the words to fit your lesson. You *CAN* sing!! If you have trouble, (1) learn to sing in the range of your speaking voice - you'll hit more notes; (2) practice to the radio/tape/cd in your car - and if you're trying to learn a particular song, have a musical friend tape it for you so you can practice singing along; (3) sing louder and slower - you may not think you have a good voice, but your students will be far more responsive if you sing with conviction and enjoyment, rather than quietly and quickly.
If you have any questions, or are interested in learning about bringing music therapy to your school, please get in touch!